Dr. Ingmar Metzler

Pillar 3a Dashboard

Should you invest in pillar 3a this year? Compare the net outcome of a 3a contribution to an equivalent private investment. The calculations are performed for the Canton of Zürich.

Personal Details

Investment Assumptions

Advanced Configuration
Advanced: Existing Wealth & Macroeconomics

Existing Portfolio

Your current balances determine which tax brackets apply. They are not shown in the chart — only this year's contribution is compared.

Macroeconomic Assumptions

Pillar 3a Net Value
Private Net Value
Difference
Withdrawal Tax
Initial Tax Savings
Methodology & Assumptions

The calculator compares two strategies based on the same economic sacrifice: investing a given pre-tax amount into pillar 3a, versus investing its post-tax equivalent privately (the gross amount minus the marginal income tax incurred by foregoing the 3a deduction).

3a path: Tax-free compounding at return − fee. At withdrawal a one-off capital-benefits tax is deducted (Canton of Zürich rates).

Private path: Compounding at return − fee − tax_drag, minus annual wealth tax (Zürich, Einfache Staatssteuer); No additional tax at liquidation (capital gains on movable private wealth are tax-free in Switzerland).

Prior balances & marginal taxes: Existing pillar 3a balance and private portfolio are grown in parallel to the contribution to determine the correct tax bracket each year. The marginal wealth tax charged to this year's private contribution equals wealthTax(priorpr + contrib) − wealthTax(priorpr). Likewise, the withdrawal tax is the marginal difference: withdrawalTax(prior3a + contrib) − withdrawalTax(prior3a). This ensures the chart and KPIs reflect only the impact of this year's decision, at the correct marginal tax bracket.

Wealth tax brackets follow the published cantonal schedule (Einfache Staatssteuer) and are multiplied by the Steuerfuss (cantonal 95 % + municipal multiplier entered above) to obtain the total wealth tax.

Tax Precision: Withdrawal taxes are calculated using exact 2026 progressive tax brackets for both the Federal (Direkte Bundessteuer) and Zürich Cantonal (Einfache Staatssteuer) levels, executing the legal 1/5th and 1/20th calculation methodologies, respectively and taking into account the minimal 2% tax for the latter. If selected, inlfation adjustments to the tax brackets are taken into account.

Limitations: Both prior balances are grown with the same return / fee assumptions as the new contribution. No stochastic returns or multi-account staggering is modelled.

Disclaimer

This calculator is provided for informational and educational purposes only and does not constitute financial, tax, or investment advice. The results are based on simplified models and publicly available tax data for the Canton of Zürich and the State of Switzerland; they may not reflect your individual circumstances, future legislative changes, or the full complexity of Swiss tax law.

No reliance should be placed on the outputs of this tool when making financial or investment decisions. Always consult a qualified financial advisor or tax professional before acting on any information presented here. The author accepts no liability for any loss or damage arising from the use of, or reliance on, this calculator.

Privacy: This calculator runs in your browser. No input data is permanently stored or sold to third parties.

Advantage
View Chart